The Psychology Of Email Subject Lines And How To Use It To Your Advantage

As more and more businesses embrace email marketing as a core component of their marketing strategy, it’s important to understand the psychology of email subject lines. Why? Because the subject line is what drives your recipient to open the email and engage with you further.

1. Appeal To Emotions

One of the key aspects of email subject lines is appealing to emotions. This can be done by making the subject line personalized to the recipient. Make them feel special and show that you care about their needs. You can also use humor or curiosity to grab their attention. Here’s an example of how you can use emotions to create a catchy subject line: “Having a bad day? Here’s something to make you smile”.

2. Use Urgency

A sense of urgency can go a long way in convincing someone to open an email. It creates a sense of importance and promotes action. To create an effective sense of urgency use words and phrases like: “Now”, “Limited time offer”, “Don’t Miss Out”, “Exclusive Offer” and “Hurry”. However, be careful not to use urgency too often, or it can lead to distrust or apathy among your audience.

3. Keep it Concise

The ideal email subject line is 6-10 words long. Research shows that longer subject lines are less likely to be read and have lower open rates. So aim for conciseness and clarity in your subject lines. Make sure the subject line of your emails directly matches the message within. For example, if you are promoting a limited-time sale, use “Hurry Up! Last chance to get 30% off” instead of “We are having a sale today”.

4. Use Numbers

Another effective tactic to increase engagement with your email is to use numbers in your email subject lines. It creates a sense of orderliness and structure. People are attracted to lists, facts and statistics. Try using interesting numbers, such as “10 Ways to Improve Your Work-Life Balance” or “4 Secrets To Achieve Success in 2022”.

5. Test and Measure

Once you have created effective email subject lines, it’s time to measure their effectiveness. This can be done through A/B testing. This method helps you understand what type of subject line resonates with your audience. The test typically involves creating multiple versions of the same email and sending them to different segments of your email list. Once a sufficient number of opens have been registered, check the results to see which version was more successful.

The Power Of Curiosity In Email Subject Lines

One technique that has been used effectively is to utilize the power of curiosity in email subject lines. Curious subject lines have been proven to pique the interest of recipients and get them to open your emails.

1. Personalize your subject lines: Personalizing your subject line with the recipient’s name is one way of grabbing their attention. But it’s not enough. Use personalization to create a sense of curiosity in the reader. For instance, use their recent activity or interest to create a personalized subject line that will inquisitive. For example, you could say, “Sarah, we’ve found your dream bicycle,” or “Jane, you need to see this report today” to evoke curiosity and ensure they open the email.

2. Use Open-ended questions: Open-ended questions are an excellent way of provoking someone’s curiosity. They’re intriguing because they ask for an answer that isn’t straight forward, leaving the recipient to wonder and read on. Use questions that are related to the topic of your email. For example, “Do you know the top four reasons why customers shop with us?,” or “What’s the best way to avoid writer’s block when writing a blog post?” Inquisitive elements in the email subject line will make the reader want to open your email.

3. Use facts and numbers: Facts and figures can be appealing when used creatively. They’re a quick snapshot of information that trigger curiosity, especially if they’re accurate and intriguing. Using a figure in your subject line is a great way to add perspective to your email and draw the reader inquisitively. Examples could include “84% increase in sales revenue,” “99% of customers love our product,” or “3 quick tips to increase productivity by 50%” These types of subject lines will encourage the recipient to open your email to see the numbers behind the claims.

4. Use Cliffhangers: Cliffhangers work like a charm in movies and TV shows, so there’s no reason not to use them in your emails. The primary idea behind cliffhangers is to keep your audience curious and in suspense, so they keep reading or watching. Use cliffhangers in the subject of your emails by dangling the bait and leaving your readers wanting to know more. Examples of such phrases could include “The Shocking Truth About…” or “Wait till you see what happened…”

5. KISS: Keep it Short and Sweet: The power of brevity is an essential factor in crafting email subject lines. As a rule of thumb, it is recommended to keep your subject lines to fewer than ten words. Don’t lose your holder’s attention by being too long-winded or descriptive. Instead, craft your subject line with KISS (Keep it short and sweet) in mind. Your subject line must be easily readable, simple and evoke curiosity in the reader.

Using Emotional Triggers To Capture Attention In Subject Lines

The subject line needs to capture the readers’ attention, stand out, and be compelling. The best way to achieve this is by creating emotional triggers in the email subject lines. 

Whether to make the recipient curious, excited, or happy, emotional triggers create an emotional connection with the reader, translating to increased open rates, click rates and lead generation. Here’s why you should start using emotional triggers in your email subject lines.

1. Emotional triggers make your emails stand out.

A good email subject line should make the recipient curious, and creating an emotional connection is one way to achieve that. People respond emotionally to things they find appealing, and if your email subject line piques their interest, the chances of them clicking and reading the whole email increase. 

You can create an emotional connection through words that evoke curiosity, such as “secret,” “surprise,” “hidden,” “exclusive,” or “don’t miss out.” You should also consider making your subject lines short, punchy, and to the point, as this will create a sense of urgency that will encourage readers to open the email.

2. Emotional triggers improve brand recognition.

Human emotion is a powerful force that can drive us to complete actions that we may otherwise not have taken. With the right words, you can create emotional responses that drive action and lead to customer retention. 

Emotional triggers can help you establish a brand voice that aligns with the aspirations of your customers, leading to improved brand recognition and loyalty. For example, if you are a health and wellness brand, using emotional triggers like “revitalizing” or “energizing” in your subject lines can create a sense of purpose and wellness, which resonates positively with your customers.

3. Emotional triggers encourage sharing.

People love sharing content that they find relatable, funny, or interesting, and using emotional triggers in your email subject lines can increase the chance of your email being shared with friends and family. 

When you create an emotional connection with your readers, they are more likely to forward your email to people they know, increasing the potential for increased traffic, conversions, and brand awareness. You can include emotional triggers like “inspiring,” “amazing,” “heartfelt,” or “passionate,” in your subject lines to create a sense of warmth and connection.

4. Emotional triggers improve conversion rates.

At the end of the day, the ultimate goal of email marketing is to convert prospects into customers. Using emotional triggers to create compelling email subject lines can improve conversion rates. 

By connecting with readers on an emotional level, you create a personal relationship that can lead to a higher level of engagement with your brand. You can use emotional triggers like “limited time,” “final chance,” “free gift,” or “offer ends today” to create a sense of urgency that drives action.

Leveraging Social Proof To Increase Engagement In Subject Lines

Social proof can come in many forms – customer testimonials, social media likes and shares, celebrity endorsements, etc. When it comes to email subject lines, social proof can be especially powerful because it gives the reader a reason to believe that your message is important and worth reading.

Here are some different types of social proof that you can use in your email subject lines:

1. User-generated content – featuring user-generated content, such as photos or reviews, in your subject lines is a great way to tap into the power of social proof. By showing that other people are enjoying your product/service, you can increase the perceived value of your brand in the eyes of your audience.

2. Awards and accolades – if your brand has won any awards or received any accolades, make sure to mention them in your subject lines. This is especially effective if the award is well-known or prestigious.

3. Social media mentions – if your brand is being talked about on social media, use that to your advantage. Include quotes from people who have mentioned your brand in their posts, or mention how many likes or shares your latest social media post has received.

4. Endorsements – featuring an endorsement from a celebrity or influencer can be a powerful way to leverage social proof in your email subject lines. Just make sure that the endorsement is authentic and relevant to your brand.

5. Statistics – including statistics in your subject line can be a great way to demonstrate the effectiveness of your product/service. For example, “88% of customers who used our product saw an improvement in…” or “Our product has been downloaded over 1 million times!”

Building Anticipation And Excitement Through Subject Lines

Email marketing is one of the most effective ways to reach your prospects and customers. However, getting people to open your emails is not easy. With all the clutter and spam in people’s inboxes, it takes a lot of effort to make your emails stand out. That’s where email subject lines come into play. 

A well-crafted subject line can make or break the success of your email campaign.

1. Keep it short and sweet. Your subject line should contain around 50 characters or less. People are more likely to open and read emails that have shorter subject lines. Also, keep in mind that a significant percentage of people access their emails through mobile devices, so your subject line needs to be mobile-friendly.

2. Be specific and clear. Your subject line should be specific about what’s inside the email, and it should create a sense of urgency. For instance, if your email contains a limited-time offer, highlight it in the subject line. People are more likely to open emails that have time-sensitive deals.

3. Use power words. Power words are words that evoke emotions and grab people’s attention. They can be words that create a sense of urgency or excitement, such as “limited time,” “exclusive offer,” “pre-sale,” “free,” “new,” or “hot.” However, use them sparingly and only where appropriate. Overusing power words can make your subject lines sound spammy.

4. Personalize your subject lines. Personalization can increase open rates. Use the recipient’s name if possible, or include details that are relevant to them. For example, if you’re sending an email to customers who made a recent purchase, use the subject line, “Thank you for your recent purchase – here’s something special for you!”

5. Test and analyze. Don’t be afraid to experiment with different subject lines and see what works best for your audience. Use A/B testing to compare different subject lines’ open rates and analyze your email campaigns’ success over time.

Crafting Subject Lines That Tap Into Recipients’ Aspirations And Desires

To ensure that your emails catch the attention of your recipients, you must craft subject lines that tap into their aspirations and desires.

1. Know your audience: To craft subject lines that appeal to your recipients’ aspirations and desires, you must know your audience. You need to understand their needs, their interests, and their wants to create subject lines that resonate with them. Gather data about your subscribers and segment them based on demographics, behavior, and interests. This type of information can help you create highly targeted subject lines that will resonate with specific segments of your audience.

2. Emotional triggers: Emotions drive people’s actions, and tapping into your recipients’ emotions is an effective way to increase your open rates. Use emotional triggers in your subject lines to appeal to your subscribers’ aspirations and desires. Words like “you,” “new,” “save,” “free,” and “limited time” can grab the attention of your audience and create a sense of urgency, which increases their desire to open your emails.

3. Personalization: Personalized subject lines have been proven to increase open rates. Use the recipient’s name, location, or purchase history to create subject lines that feel personalized and relevant to them. Personalization can make a significant impact on your recipient’s perception of your brand and increase their loyalty to your brand.

4. Keep it short and sweet: Subject lines that are too long or complicated can turn off your recipients. Keep your subject lines short, concise, and to the point. A subject line with 50 characters or less is ideal because it can be easily read on mobile devices and will still convey your message.

5. Test and optimize: No matter how perfect you think your subject lines are, you must test and optimize them to ensure that they are resonating with your audience. Use A/B testing to compare different subject lines and see which one performs better. Use the data to tweak and optimize your subject lines until you find ones that consistently perform well.

Using Cognitive Biases To Your Advantage In Subject Lines

One way to make your subject lines more effective is by using cognitive biases, which are shortcuts in our brain that help us make decisions.

1. The Scarcity Bias

The scarcity bias is the idea that if something is limited in quantity or time, it becomes more desirable. You can use this in your subject lines by creating a sense of urgency or exclusivity. For example, “Limited time offer: 50% off for the next 24 hours” or “Exclusive access to our new product launch”. These types of subject lines tap into the fear of missing out (FOMO) and can be very effective in getting people to open your email.

2. The Social Proof Bias

The social proof bias is the idea that people are influenced by others who are similar to them. You can use this in your subject lines by highlighting social proof, such as customer reviews, ratings, or testimonials. For example, “Join over 10,000 happy customers” or “5-star rating from our customers”. These types of subject lines tap into the idea that if others like it, I probably will too.

3. The Authority Bias

The authority bias is the idea that people are more likely to obey an authority figure. You can use this in your subject lines by positioning yourself as an expert or authority in your field. For example, “As seen on Forbes” or “Expert advice from a top industry leader”. These types of subject lines tap into the idea that if someone is an expert, their opinion is more trustworthy and valuable.

4. The Recency Bias

The recency bias is the idea that people give more weight to recent events or information. You can use this in your subject lines by referencing current events or trends. For example, “The latest trends in digital marketing” or “Breaking news in the world of ecommerce”. These types of subject lines tap into the idea that if something is recent, it’s more relevant and important.

5. The Curiosity Bias

The curiosity bias is the idea that people are naturally curious and want to know more. You can use this in your subject lines by creating curiosity gaps or asking questions. For example, “The one thing you’re doing wrong on social media” or “Are you making these common email mistakes?”. These types of subject lines tap into the idea that if someone is curious, they’ll want to click and find out more.

How To Create Subject Lines That Evoke Positive Emotions

With so much competition for attention in your audience’s inbox, you need to make sure that your subject lines stand out from the crowd. Creating subject lines that evoke positive emotions is one way to do just that.

1. Understand the psychology behind positive emotions

Before we dive into how to create positive subject lines, it’s important to understand the psychology behind positive emotions. Research has shown that human beings are wired to respond more positively to emotions such as happiness, excitement, and curiosity. When we experience these emotions, our brains release dopamine, which is the neurotransmitter associated with pleasure and reward. By tapping into these emotions with your subject lines, you can increase the likelihood that your audience will open and engage with your emails.

2. Use power words

Power words are words that have emotional impact. They grab attention, evoke curiosity, or inspire a sense of urgency. Examples of power words that can be used in subject lines include words like “amazing,” “exclusive,” “limited time,” and “secret.” These types of words evoke a sense of excitement and can increase the likelihood that your audience will open your emails.

3. Personalize your subject lines

Personalization can also play a role in evoking positive emotions in your audience. By using your audience’s first name in the subject line, for example, you can create a sense of familiarity and connection. This can lead to positive emotions such as happiness or a sense of being valued. Additionally, personalization can increase the sense of relevance of your emails, which can lead to greater engagement.

4. Highlight benefits, not features

Another approach to creating positive subject lines is to focus on the benefits of your products or services, rather than their features. Benefits describe what your products or services will do for your audience. Features describe their characteristics. By focusing on benefits, you can tap into emotions like excitement or satisfaction. For example, a subject line like “Transform your mornings with our energy-boosting smoothie” emphasizes the benefit of the product (energy-boosting) rather than its features (ingredients).

5. Test and analyze your subject lines

Finally, it’s important to test and analyze your subject lines to see what works best for your audience. A/B testing is a useful strategy for testing subject lines. This involves sending two versions of an email to a small sample of your audience and measuring which one gets better engagement. You can then use this information to optimize your subject lines for maximum impact.

The Psychology Of Exclusivity And Its Effect On Subject Line Engagement

In today’s world, consumers are constantly bombarded with marketing messages on a daily basis. This makes it difficult for businesses to stand out and capture the attention of their audience. 

One strategy that has proven to be effective is through the use of exclusivity. This tactic creates a sense of importance and urgency among consumers, making them more likely to engage with the message. But how does exclusivity impact subject line engagement and what is the psychology behind it?

1. The Theory of Scarcity

One of the main reasons why exclusivity works is due to the Theory of Scarcity. This theory suggests that people value things that are scarce because they believe that they are more valuable and harder to obtain. This concept can be applied to subject lines by creating a sense of limited availability or time sensitivity. When consumers see subject lines like “Exclusive offer for a limited time only” or “Act now, limited spots available”, they are more likely to open the email to avoid missing out.

2. The Power of FOMO

Exclusivity also taps into the concept of FOMO or “fear of missing out”. This is the fear that people have of missing out on a unique opportunity or experience. When businesses create a sense of exclusivity through their subject lines, consumers feel like they are part of an exclusive club and don’t want to be left out. This is why subject lines like “You’re invited – exclusive access” or “Be the first to know” can be so effective in engaging the audience.

3. The Importance of Personalization

Personalization is key in creating exclusivity through subject lines. One way to do this is by using the recipient’s name in the subject line, which creates a sense of importance and individuality. Another tactic is to segment your list based on behavior or interests, and then tailor the subject line to each group. For example, if you have a group of subscribers that have purchased a specific product, you could use a subject line like “Exclusive offer for our top customers”.

4. The Role of Curiosity

Another psychological factor that plays a role in exclusivity and subject line engagement is curiosity. Humans are naturally curious creatures, and subject lines that pique their interest can result in higher open rates. Using subject lines like “You won’t believe what we’re offering” or “Secrets to…” can create a sense of mystery and intrigue, encouraging the recipient to click through and learn more.

5. The Importance of Delivering on the Promise

Finally, it’s important to note that exclusivity can be a double-edged sword. While it can be effective in engaging the audience, it can also lead to disappointment if the promised exclusivity doesn’t deliver. This can result in a loss of trust and loyalty among your subscribers. Make sure to follow through on the promise made in the subject line and provide a valuable and exclusive experience for the recipient.

How To Create Subject Lines That Appeal To Recipients’ Need For Self-expression

As marketers, we know that subject lines are the deciding factor that determines whether an email will be opened or not. In fact, it is said that subject lines are the single most important aspect of your email marketing campaign.

However, crafting an effective subject line can be challenging, and making it stand out from the rest can be even more complicated. Have you ever considered that your subject line needs to appeal to the recipient’s need for self-expression?

1. Personalization: Personalization is an effective way to appeal to your recipients’ need for self-expression. Receive an email with your name in the subject line can give you a feeling of importance. Use recipient-specific data, such as purchase history, browsing behavior, or location, to make your subject lines highly personalized.

2. Emojis: Emojis are a proven way of humanizing your subject lines, and adding emotional value. Placing just the right emoji in the subject line can help to engage your clients on an emotional level and adds a lighthearted element to your brand.

3. Controversial copy: Being controversial is one way to grab your recipient’s attention, and at the same time tackle topics that spark conversations. However, using controversial copy as an email subject line can be tricky. Ensure the line is not crossing the line, and never take sides that could offend your customers.

4. Urgency: Creating a sense of urgency in email subject lines encourages recipients to act before it is too late. Add exclusive offers or limited time discounts, subject lines that create urgency are highly effective and leads to increased open rates.

5. Minimalist approach: Less is more when it comes to subject lines. Be bold, concise, direct, and try to say as much as possible with the fewest words possible. Speak proudly about your brand but do not oversell or spam as this will have the opposite effect on your recipients.

Using Psychological Principles To Craft Subject Lines That Drive Action

Crafting a subject line that drives action requires a good understanding of psychology and what motivates people to take action.

1. Human Curiosity

Curiosity is a powerful emotion that drives human behavior. Tap into this emotion by writing subject lines that tease the recipient and encourage them to open the email to find out more. For example, a subject line that says “What’s Inside?” is a great way to arouse curiosity and encourage the recipient to open your email.

2. Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)

The fear of missing out is a powerful psychological principle. People don’t want to miss out on something that everyone else is doing or experiencing. You can tap into this principle by crafting subject lines that create a sense of urgency and encourage the recipient to take action. For example, a subject line that says “Last Chance to Get 50% Off” will create a sense of urgency and encourage the recipient to open your email and take advantage of the offer.

3. Social Proof

Social proof is the principle that people are influenced by the actions of others. Using social proof in your subject lines can be a great way to drive action. For example, a subject line that says “Join the Thousands of Other Customers Who Have Saved Money” is a great way to use social proof to encourage the recipient to take action.

4. Personalization

Personalization is the principle of tailoring your message to the individual recipient. Personalized subject lines have been shown to have higher open rates than non-personalized subject lines. Use the recipient’s name in the subject line or reference something that is specific to them to create a sense of personalization. For example, a subject line that says “Sarah, Here’s Your Exclusive Offer” is a great way to create a personalized subject line that encourages the recipient to open your email.

5. Clarity

Clarity is critical when it comes to subject lines. A subject line that is unclear or vague will likely be ignored. Keep your subject lines clear, concise, and to the point. Use language that is easy to understand and avoid jargon or technical terms that may confuse the recipient.

Conclusion

The psychology of effective email subject lines can be a powerful tool for increasing engagement and getting recipients to take action. Crafting subject lines that tap into curiosity, emotional triggers, social proof, anticipation and excitement, aspirations and desires, cognitive biases, positive emotions, exclusivity and need for self-expression will not only capture attention but also give you an opportunity to perform various experiments to identify which approach is more effective in obtaining desired results. 

Putting yourself in your clients’ shoes will help you understand the value they will receive from your emails and create irresistible subject lines accordingly. With a bit of creativity and understanding of your audience’s needs you can start having conversations with your users and build strong relationships in the process.

References 

https://mailchimp.com/help/best-practices-for-email-subject-lines/

https://blog.hubspot.com/marketing/improve-your-email-subject-line

The 177 Best Email Subject Lines & Templates